| Season 46 | user swat (FALCONS) | 41 | Kam (COLTS) | 31 |
| Season 45 | Keenis VII (BROWNS) | 48 | Easy Macaroni (EAGLES) | 43 |
| Season 44 | Easy Macaroni (EAGLES) | 48 | Keenis VII (BROWNS) | 21 |
| Season 43 | Easy Macaroni (EAGLES) | 31 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (STEELERS) | 24 |
| Season 42 | user swat (BENGALS) | 49 | Kid Mescudii (RAMS) | 13 |
| Season 41 | user swat (BENGALS) | 52 | TwoEagle12 (LIONS) | 7 |
| Season 40 | Arod12thMan (CHIEFS) | 35 | BHM Beezy (FALCONS) | 28 |
| Season 39 | user swat (LIONS) | 31 | Glenwood Sosa (JAGUARS) | 21 |
| Season 38 | Ganderson (BRONCOS) | 28 | user swat (LIONS) | 20 |
| Season 37 | user swat (FALCONS) | 49 | Glenwood Sosa (RAIDERS) | 17 |
| Season 36 | user swat (FALCONS) | 44 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (CHARGERS) | 21 |
| Season 35 | TwoEagle12 (BUCCANEERS) | 56 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (CHARGERS) | 32 |
| Season 34 | Keenis VII (BROWNS) | 26 | iTz iRock23 (VIKINGS) | 13 |
| Season 33 | Keenis VII (BROWNS) | 35 | Diner (RAMS) | 21 |
| Season 32 | Kid Mescudii (CHARGERS) | 20 | Glenwood Sosa (PANTHERS) | 14 |
| Season 31 | JOSHER (49ERS) | 28 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (JAGUARS) | 17 |
| Season 30 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (LIONS) | 34 | ZenPirates (JETS) | 20 |
| Season 29 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (LIONS) | 20 | Diner (CHARGERS) | 7 |
| Season 28 | Wit (JAGUARS) | 23 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (LIONS) | 17 |
| Season 27 | Wit (JAGUARS) | 27 | user swat (FALCONS) | 7 |
| Season 26 | user swat (FALCONS) | 27 | Glenwood Sosa (RAIDERS) | 14 |
| Season 25 | JOSHER (CARDINALS) | 48 | BHM Beezy (TEXANS) | 14 |
| Season 24 | JOSHER (FALCONS) | 38 | Wit (BILLS) | 17 |
| Season 23 | Wit (BILLS) | 35 | user swat (SAINTS) | 33 |
| Season 22 | user swat (FALCONS) | 9 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (STEELERS) | 6 |
| Season 21 | user swat (FALCONS) | 44 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (STEELERS) | 23 |
| Season 20 | user swat (FALCONS) | 23 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (STEELERS) | 17 |
| Season 19 | Diner (JETS) | 35 | Wit (VIKINGS) | 14 |
| Season 18 | Wit (JAGUARS) | 17 | Diner (LIONS) | 16 |
| Season 17 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (RAVENS) | 21 | EddieLoks (COMMANDERS) | 20 |
| Season 16 | Kid Mescudii (BROWNS) | 14 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (LIONS) | 10 |
| Season 15 | KERNEL (BENGALS) | 30 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (LIONS) | 3 |
| Season 14 | user swat (FALCONS) | 27 | Thavage (DOLPHINS) | 18 |
| Season 13 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (LIONS) | 19 | Thavage (DOLPHINS) | 3 |
| Season 12 | Thavage (DOLPHINS) | 17 | user swat (FALCONS) | 3 |
| Season 11 | Wit (PATRIOTS) | 23 | Thavage (SEAHAWKS) | 13 |
| Season 10 | Thavage (SEAHAWKS) | 21 | Prelude (RAIDERS) | 10 |
| Season 9 | Checkmarc5(bakd) (BRONCOS) | 28 | Joe Schmoe (BEARS) | 10 |
| Season 8 | user swat (FALCONS) | 22 | Kid Mescudii (CHARGERS) | 14 |
| Season 7 | Thavage (DOLPHINS) | 26 | Diner (COMMANDERS) | 16 |
| Season 6 | Kid Mescudii (CHARGERS) | 19 | user swat (FALCONS) | 14 |
| Season 5 | Prelude (COWBOYS) | 21 | Wit (BENGALS) | 14 |
| Season 4 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (PACKERS) | 28 | Wit (BENGALS) | 23 |
| Season 3 | Steve is chat banned (CARDINALS) | 27 | W3STW00D (Coммιѕн) (JAGUARS) | 17 |
| Season 2 | Wit (BRONCOS) | 14 | SOUTHERN (PANTHERS) | 12 |
| Season 1 | Wit (BRONCOS) | 16 | Steve is chat banned (CARDINALS) | 3 |